Case result · Engine / Hybrid Transmission

New Engine at 366 Miles, New Transmission at 14,000 — Kia Bought Back This Niro Hybrid

Two major powertrain replacements and 57 countable days out of service.

$12,536recovered for the client
1.06xthe statutory refund
57countable days out of service
8repair visits

The math

What this client actually received

Every figure below comes from the settlement documents in this case. Nothing is rounded up, and nothing is left out.

What the client received

Statutory refundThe formula written into the Song-Beverly Act $11,882.25
Civil penaltiesAwarded where the manufacturer's failure was willful plus$654.37
Paid to the client $12,536.62
Loan / lease balance cleared$24,339.93Paid directly to the lender by Kia America, Inc., on top of the figure above
Attorney fees$0Paid by the manufacturer, not the client
Vehicle
2024 Kia Niro Hybrid
VIN
KNDCR3LE2R5••••••
Bought
Used
Contract
Lease
Miles at delivery
179
Price
$31,489.00
Manufacturer
Kia America, Inc.
Outcome
Buyback + civil penalties
  • $12,536.62 to the client
  • $24,340 lease paid off
  • Engine replaced at 366 miles
  • 57 countable days out of service

The case

Engine replaced at 366 miles — then the hybrid transmission was replaced too

Our client leased a 2024 Kia Niro hybrid. Ten days after delivery, with 366 miles on it, it was back at the dealer with a loud rattle and vibration from the engine.

The dealer found a cylinder misfire and, using a borescope, damage inside the cylinder block. The engine's long block was replaced, then the catalytic manifold. Weeks later an oxygen sensor failed. At about 14,400 miles, a flashing hybrid warning light led to a transmission-related fault, and the transmission was replaced. The hybrid system warning came back again later, and the vehicle was towed in.

The repair record

57 countable days out of service

The first visit alone lasted 33 consecutive days. Across eight visits the Niro spent 59 days in the shop, 57 of them countable.

  1. 0133 days

    366 miles

    Loud rattling noise and vibration from the engine

    What the dealer did

    Misfire code P0301; borescope found cylinder block damage; long block (engine) replaced, then catalytic manifold replaced after P0420

    • Long block (engine)
    • Catalytic manifold
    Counts toward days out of serviceVerified
  2. 022 days

    421 miles

    Check engine light on

    What the dealer did

    DTC P0030; HO2 sensor replaced

    • HO2 sensor
    Counts toward days out of serviceVerified
  3. 031 day

    6,049 miles

    Recall / maintenance

    What the dealer did

    Recall SC332 floor wiring inspection and reroute; oil change

    Counts toward days out of serviceN/A (recall)
  4. 041 day

    12,261 miles

    Maintenance

    What the dealer did

    Oil change / tire pressure

    Not countedN/A (maintenance)
  5. 0513 days

    14,366 miles

    Hybrid warning light flashing on and off

    What the dealer did

    DTC P174494 related to the transmission; transmission replaced

    • Transmission
    Counts toward days out of serviceVerified
  6. 061 day

    15,116 miles

    Vehicle shakes when accelerating or stopping

    What the dealer did

    Could not duplicate; no codes

    • Engine or transmission
    Counts toward days out of serviceNot verified
  7. 071 day

    18,813 miles

    Maintenance

    What the dealer did

    Oil change / inspection

    Not countedN/A (maintenance)
  8. 087 days

    20,234 miles

    Towed in — hybrid system light on

    What the dealer did

    Vehicle still in service at time of itemization

    • Hybrid system
    Counts toward days out of serviceNot verified (in progress)

The turning point

Why the manufacturer paid

An engine replacement and a transmission replacement on the same car in its first year and a half is exactly what the Song-Beverly Act was written for. The first repair alone put the car past the 30-day threshold.

The result

How it ended

Kia repurchased the Niro and paid off the $24,339.93 lease balance. Our client received $12,536.62: $11,882.25 in statutory damages plus $654.37 in civil penalties/additional recovery.

What this case shows

If a major component is replaced early in ownership, and then another one fails, talk to a lemon law attorney. That pattern matters.

Free case review

Think you have the same problem?

Did your car need a new engine or transmission in its first year? You may qualify for a buyback. The review is free.

Skip to content