2014-2026 Model S owners: touchscreen recall 21V035, Autopilot recall 23V838, 12V battery failures, and more. Free CA lemon law case review.
The 2014-2026 Tesla Model S carries an unusually long list of NHTSA-mandated recalls, including one where a federal safety agency sent Tesla a formal recall demand letter after Tesla declined to act voluntarily on the eMMC touchscreen failure (21V-035). Recalls have also covered the Autopilot system linked to fatal crashes (23V-838), 12-volt battery failures that leave owners stranded, and rearview camera loss. If your Model S has left you stranded, shown a black screen when you needed the backup camera, or behaved erratically on Autopilot, California law may entitle you to a buyback or replacement vehicle.
The issues owners report most, ranked by severity — each one verified against a cited NHTSA source.
In a frontal crash: airbag deploys but tears, does not fully inflate, or collapses prematurely; occupant contacts steering wheel or yoke with less-than-expected cushioning; airbag warning light may not be predictive of this failure mode pre-crash
Vehicle continues driving on Autosteer without adequate warnings when driver is inattentive; system allows extended hands-off-wheel operation; Autosteer may disengage suddenly without sufficient advance alert; vehicle may fail to slow for traffic controls while Autosteer is engaged
Vehicle rolls through all-way stop intersections without fully stopping; drives through stale yellow lights without slowing; travels faster than posted speed limit in variable speed zones; makes unexpected lane changes out of turn-only lanes while FSD Beta is active
Seat belt feels unusually loose or does not retract properly; belt anchor visually misaligned or separated from pretensioner; belt may pull free from lower anchor point during normal use or crash event
Clunking or popping noise from front suspension, especially during low-speed parking maneuvers; sudden change in steering feel; vehicle pulls sharply to one side; visible damage to front suspension linkage; in extreme cases, loss of vehicle control
Center touchscreen goes blank or unresponsive; rearview camera fails to display when shifting into reverse; rear defrost and defog settings stop working; exterior turn signals may stop functioning; on-screen alert appears warning of imminent eMMC failure
A settled Margarian Law case on this exact model, published with the actual settlement math.
Open any defect for the symptoms and why it matters for a California lemon-law claim. Each is tied to a cited NHTSA source.
Vehicle continues driving on Autosteer without adequate warnings when driver is inattentive; system allows extended hands-off-wheel operation; Autosteer may disengage suddenly without sufficient advance alert; vehicle may fail to slow for traffic controls while Autosteer is engaged
The largest Autopilot-related recall in U.S. history at 2,031,220 vehicles. At least 13 fatality crashes identified in predicate investigation where driver misuse played an apparent role. NHTSA's subsequent Recall Query RQ24009 questions remedy adequacy — ongoing regulatory scrutiny. Crashes caused by Autosteer disengagement or inadequate warnings create direct personal injury and lemon-law exposure.
OTA software update adding additional controls and alerts, simplified engagement/disengagement, additional checks approaching traffic controls, and suspension from Autosteer use for drivers repeatedly failing to demonstrate sustained driving responsibility.
Vehicle rolls through all-way stop intersections without fully stopping; drives through stale yellow lights without slowing; travels faster than posted speed limit in variable speed zones; makes unexpected lane changes out of turn-only lanes while FSD Beta is active
NHTSA-confirmed illegal behavior (running stop signs, exceeding speed limits) by an OEM-enabled software feature. Two sequential recalls (22V037 and 23V085) indicate Tesla's initial remedy was insufficient. Owner reliance on a marketed autonomous-driving feature that operates unlawfully supports misrepresentation and safety-defect claims.
OTA software update. Rolling-stop feature disabled via firmware 2021.44.30.15 (22V037). Broader FSD Beta intersection and speed compliance deficiencies remedied by OTA update under 23V085.
Seat belt feels unusually loose or does not retract properly; belt anchor visually misaligned or separated from pretensioner; belt may pull free from lower anchor point during normal use or crash event
A seat belt that can detach in a crash is a Category A safety defect (direct occupant protection failure). FMVSS-violating safety defects establish the predicate for lemon-law claims without requiring a prior repair attempt in California (Civil Code §1793.2(d)(2) — substantial impairment). Affected 2021-2023 Model S owners should verify recall completion.
Tesla Service inspects and reconnects or replaces seat belt assemblies at no charge under recall 23V488. OEM service bulletin SB-23-20-004.
In a frontal crash: airbag deploys but tears, does not fully inflate, or collapses prematurely; occupant contacts steering wheel or yoke with less-than-expected cushioning; airbag warning light may not be predictive of this failure mode pre-crash
A defective airbag that tears on deployment is a Catastrophic safety defect. FMVSS 208 violation establishes federal safety standard non-compliance. Any owner involved in a crash where airbag failure caused injury may have concurrent product-liability and lemon-law claims. California lemon-law allows claims on safety-related defects regardless of number of repair attempts if the defect cannot safely be repaired.
Replace driver airbag assembly at no charge under recall 24V967. OEM SB-24-20-001.
Clunking or popping noise from front suspension, especially during low-speed parking maneuvers; sudden change in steering feel; vehicle pulls sharply to one side; visible damage to front suspension linkage; in extreme cases, loss of vehicle control
NHTSA's closure statement (August 14, 2024) explicitly states it 'does not constitute a finding by the Agency that a safety-related defect is not present.' China issued a recall for ~30,000 vehicles covering equivalent suspension components. Owners with documented suspension fractures — particularly outside the narrow TSB VIN range — have strong defect claims even without a U.S. recall. Repeated component failures or dealer refusals to repair outside TSB scope support lemon-law arguments.
Replace front suspension fore link assemblies. Tesla's 2017 service bulletin covers a narrow VIN range; vehicles outside that range may require negotiation with Tesla or out-of-pocket payment. No U.S. recall was ever issued.
Center touchscreen goes blank or unresponsive; rearview camera fails to display when shifting into reverse; rear defrost and defog settings stop working; exterior turn signals may stop functioning; on-screen alert appears warning of imminent eMMC failure
Loss of the rearview camera is a direct FMVSS 111 compliance failure and renders the vehicle legally unsafe to operate. NHTSA issued a formal recall demand letter after Tesla did not voluntarily recall — a documented adversarial regulatory escalation. Total failure rate exceeded 100,000+ vehicles; many owners incurred substantial repair costs prior to recall. Repeated service visits for eMMC replacement or interim OTA failures support substantial-impairment and multiple-repair-attempt arguments.
Tesla replaces the eMMC chip or entire Visual Compute Module daughterboard at no charge under recall 21V035. Owners who previously paid out-of-pocket are entitled to reimbursement. Prior OTA firmware updates (2020.24.6.11 and 2020.48.12) provided partial mitigations.
Vehicle becomes completely non-operational without warning; electronic door handles fail to extend (occupants may be trapped inside or locked out); frunk and trunk fail to open; center display goes dark; vehicle cannot be driven or charged; failure may occur even with high-voltage pack at full charge
Complete vehicle immobilization with no warning is a textbook substantial impairment under California Civil Code §1793.2. The 2021 hardware redesign (lead-acid to lithium-ion) is an OEM admission that the prior design was defective. No recall was issued despite widespread documented failures — absence of recall does not preclude lemon-law claims. Owners stranded multiple times on the same defect have strong repair-attempt arguments.
Replace 12V lead-acid battery (Tesla Service or third-party). Tesla issued an OTA software update (September 2020) optimizing 12V charging behavior from the HV pack. No recall was issued. Tesla eliminated the defect by switching to a lithium-ion 12V battery in the redesigned 2021 Model S.
Steering suddenly becomes very heavy or stiff, especially at low speeds; warning light illuminates; steering does not return to center normally; steering feel changes abruptly while driving
Sudden loss of power steering at any speed is a direct safety hazard and constitutes substantial impairment. Pre-recall steering rack replacement is expensive; owners who paid out-of-pocket prior to the 2018 recall may have reimbursement claims. California owners in non-salt regions may have lower failure rates but recall applicability is based on VIN, not geography.
Replace the entire steering rack assembly at no charge under recall 18V204.
open
The driver's frontal airbag cushion assembly contains a manufacturing defect causing the bag to tear upon deployment in a crash.
open
Software defect causes the seat belt warning light and audible chime to fail to activate when the driver is unbelted.
open
A software defect may cause cabin doors to unlock during a crash event.
open
In certain circumstances when Autosteer is engaged, the prominence and scope of the feature's controls may not be sufficient to prevent driver misuse of the SAE Level 2 advanced driver-assistance feature, including failing to keep hands on the wheel and maintain sustained driving responsibility.
open
Front-row seat belts may not be connected properly to pretensioner anchors during manufacturing and can detach from the anchor.
open
FSD Beta software may allow the vehicle to infringe upon local traffic laws or customs in certain rare circumstances, including: (1) traveling through stale yellow traffic lights without stopping; (2) inadequate static position duration at stop signs; (3) traveling faster than the posted speed limit in variable speed zones; (4) making lane changes out of turn-only lanes.
open
The infotainment CPU may overheat during Supercharger fast-charging preparation or process, causing the CPU to lag or restart, temporarily blanking the center display.
open
A software feature called 'rolling stop' allows the vehicle to travel through all-way-stop intersections at up to 5.6 mph before coming to a complete stop if certain pre-conditions are met, which violates traffic laws requiring a full stop.
open
The eMMC flash memory device is rated for approximately 3,000 program/erase cycles. Over time, normal vehicle use exhausts the chip's write endurance, causing filesystem corruption. Wear-out causes failures of center display software, and may indirectly cause loss of the rearview camera display, defrost/defog control settings, and exterior turn signal lighting.
open
The Bosch electric power-assisted steering rack uses aluminum mounting bolts susceptible to corrosion; corroded bolts may fracture, causing the EPAS system to disengage and leaving only manual (very heavy) steering effort.
Every item below comes from this vehicle's documented defects. The more you recognize, the more a free case review is worth your time.
California's Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act — commonly called the lemon law — applies to new and certified pre-owned vehicles purchased or leased in California that come with a manufacturer's warranty. If your Tesla Model S has a defect that substantially impairs its use, value, or safety, and the manufacturer has been given a reasonable number of attempts to fix it without success, you may qualify for a full buyback (refund of your purchase price, minus a mileage offset) or a replacement vehicle.
California law presumes a reasonable number of repair attempts has been exceeded if:
A lemon-law claim is not limited to vehicles that have been in accidents — it covers design and manufacturing defects present from the time of sale. Recall-confirmed defects (such as the eMMC failure, Autopilot controls, and airbag defects on the Model S) provide documented evidence that the defect existed. Owners with 12V failures and suspension fractures may also have claims even without a formal recall, because the absence of a recall does not mean the vehicle is not defective.
This is general information about California law, not legal advice. Whether your specific situation qualifies is a determination only an attorney can make.
“Could not duplicate” doesn't mean the defect isn't real. Here's exactly what to do to protect a potential California lemon-law claim.
Document the moment it happens. Photos, video, and screenshots of any warning lights — with the date and the mileage.
Get a repair order every visit — even “found nothing.” That paperwork is the foundation of a claim.
Check your VIN at nhtsa.gov/recalls. Note any recall that has no available remedy yet.
Track your out-of-service days. California law counts the cumulative days your vehicle spends in the shop.
Keep loaner & rental records. Alternate-transport paperwork during long repairs matters.
Save everything in one place. Symptoms, dates, repair orders, and every repeat visit — the intermittent ones especially.
Tesla's service model creates a specific 'cannot duplicate' trap. Many Model S defects — touchscreen freezes, Autopilot disengagement, 12V failures — are intermittent or occur only under certain conditions (cold weather, fast charging, specific software builds). Here is what to do if Tesla or a service center says they could not replicate the problem:
1. Document everything in writing. Every time a problem occurs, send a message through the Tesla app or email Tesla Service with a description, date, time, and conditions. This creates a timestamped paper trail that exists independent of service records.
2. Pull your car's data before the visit. Request your vehicle's on-board logs via the Tesla app or ask Tesla Service to pull the full data snapshot. For eMMC/MCU failures, NHTSA found error codes and filesystem-corruption logs are retained even after partial recovery.
3. Take video. A 10-second phone video of a dark touchscreen, a frozen backup camera display, or an Autopilot disengagement alert is evidence that cannot be disputed as 'no trouble found.'
4. Save your service repair orders (ROs). California requires Tesla to give you a written RO for every service visit, even if the tech finds nothing. Collect every one.
5. Note the weather and charging state. MCU CPU overtemperature failures (recall 22V296) occur during fast charging. 12V failures are worse in cold weather. These environmental details are precisely what NHTSA documented in its investigations and can link your symptom to a known defect.
6. Ask specifically whether your VIN is subject to open recalls. Tesla is required to remedy open recalls without charge. If the dealer is billing you for repair of a recalled component, that is a separate problem.
7. Consult a lemon-law attorney if the problem has not been fixed after two or more repair attempts. California law does not require you to give the manufacturer unlimited chances.
The Tesla Model S accumulates recalls across nearly every major vehicle system: infotainment, Autopilot software, steering, airbags, and seat belts. Several of these recalls came only after NHTSA applied regulatory pressure — the MCU recall was filed after a formal federal demand letter, and the Autopilot misuse recall followed a multi-year crash investigation. That pattern of regulatory escalation is relevant to lemon-law cases because it demonstrates Tesla had knowledge of the defect before the recall was filed.
For owners, the most important thing to know is that a problem does not need a recall number to be a lemon-law defect. If your Model S has repeatedly returned to service for the same issue — a touchscreen that keeps going dark, a 12V battery that has been replaced twice, suspension work that has not resolved the clunk — California law may entitle you to a replacement or refund. The Margarian Law Firm has handled Tesla lemon-law cases and can evaluate your situation at no cost to you.
— The Margarian Law team
Has your Tesla Model S had repeated touchscreen failures, Autopilot problems, a dead 12V battery, or suspension issues that Tesla has not fully resolved? You may have a lemon-law claim under California law. The Margarian Law Firm offers free, confidential case evaluations with no fee unless you win. Contact us today to find out if your Model S qualifies for a buyback or replacement.
Yes, if your Model S is a 2014-2018 model year. NHTSA recall 21V035 covers the Media Control Unit (MCU) eMMC flash memory chip, which wears out from normal use and causes the touchscreen to go blank, disables the rearview/backup camera, and can disable rear defrost and exterior turn signals. Tesla is required to replace the eMMC at no charge. If you previously paid out-of-pocket for this repair, Tesla must reimburse you. For 2021-2022 Model S vehicles, a related but distinct recall (22V296) covers the infotainment CPU overheating during fast charging and causing a blank screen. Contact Tesla Service with your VIN to confirm which recalls are open for your vehicle.
This is a known 12V auxiliary battery failure specific to pre-2021 Model S vehicles (MY 2014-2020). Even though the high-voltage drive battery appears full, a separate 12V lead-acid battery controls the electronic door handles, frunk, trunk, contactor system, and all low-voltage systems. When the 12V battery dies, the entire vehicle becomes inoperable — it cannot be driven, charged, or even opened through the power door handles. Tesla acknowledged this problem with a software mitigation in September 2020 and replaced the lead-acid design with a lithium-ion 12V battery in the redesigned 2021 Model S. No recall was issued for earlier owners. If your vehicle has been stranded by 12V failure more than once, that repeated failure may support a California lemon-law claim even without a formal recall.
Yes — multiple. The largest is recall 23V838 (December 2023), which covered 2,031,220 Tesla vehicles including Model S MY 2014-2023. NHTSA found that Autosteer's driver-monitoring controls were insufficient to prevent foreseeable misuse, and the underlying engineering analysis identified at least 13 fatal crashes where driver inattention played an apparent role. Tesla issued an OTA software update as the remedy, but NHTSA subsequently opened a query questioning whether that remedy is adequate. Additionally, FSD Beta was recalled twice for illegal driving behavior: recall 22V037 (rolling through stop signs) and recall 23V085 (running stale yellow lights, exceeding speed limits). If you brought your Model S in for Autopilot or FSD concerns before these recalls were issued, those service visits may be relevant to a lemon-law claim.
Not necessarily. A 'cannot duplicate' finding from Tesla Service does not end a lemon-law claim. California law focuses on the number of repair attempts and the total time your vehicle was out of service, not on whether the dealer successfully reproduced the defect each time. To protect your claim: (1) Document every symptom occurrence by writing to Tesla through the app or by email — this creates a timestamped record independent of dealer service notes. (2) Request your vehicle data logs from Tesla; for infotainment and software issues, error codes and system logs are often retained even when the dealer cannot observe the failure live. (3) Keep every service repair order, even those marked 'no trouble found.' Four or more repair attempts for the same non-safety defect, or two or more for a safety defect, trigger the lemon-law presumption in California — regardless of each individual outcome.
There is no U.S. recall for the front suspension fore link fracture on the Model S, but NHTSA did open and investigate the issue (preliminary evaluation opened November 30, 2020). The agency documented 426 fore link fracture instances across Model S MY 2015-2017 and Model X MY 2016-2017. Tesla issued a narrow service bulletin in 2017, but NHTSA found it covered only about 25% of the vehicles with documented failures. Importantly, NHTSA's August 2024 closure statement explicitly states it 'does not constitute a finding by the Agency that a safety-related defect is not present.' If your VIN is outside Tesla's TSB range and you have a documented fore link fracture, you may have a warranty or lemon-law claim even without a recall. China separately recalled approximately 30,000 vehicles for equivalent suspension components.
Yes. California's Song-Beverly Act applies to any defect that substantially impairs your vehicle's use, value, or safety — whether the root cause is hardware or software. Several Model S recalls were remedied by OTA updates (Autopilot controls, FSD Beta behavior, seat belt warning chime, door latch software). If the OTA fix did not resolve the problem, or if the software defect caused the vehicle to be unsafe or unusable during the period it existed, those circumstances can still support a lemon-law claim. The key question is whether the manufacturer was given a reasonable number of opportunities to fix the defect — a failed OTA and a subsequent dealer visit each count as an attempt. An attorney can evaluate whether your specific repair history meets the legal threshold.
Skip to content
